Cimasi Law Office

Why eyewitness testimony is so hard to trust in criminal law

How confident are you in your memory? What did you have for lunch last Friday? If you witnessed a crime, how sure are you that you could identify the perpetrator in a police lineup later?

Most people know that human memory is often imperfect. As time passes, details fade away. The power of suggestion, say from police questioning, can change the "facts" that you recall. Criminal cases that rely heavily on eyewitness testimony are notoriously difficult to prove beyond a reasonable doubt.



The 'cross-race effect'

There is another unfortunate but common problem that many people deal with when identifying someone else. Psychologists say that people often have trouble identifying suspects of races different than their own. This "cross-race effect" recently played a big factor in overturning a New York man's 2011 conviction for robbery recently.

The man, who is African American, was sentenced to 25 years in prison based in large part on the testimony of the victims, who were white. They each picked the defendant out of separate police lineups. This helped convince the jury despite evidence that the defendant was a mile away when the robbery happened.

On appeal, the defendant's attorney successfully argued that the trial judge should have instructed the jury about the cross-race effect. On retrial, the jury got that instruction and reportedly deliberated for less than five minutes before finding the man not guilty.

The benefits of talking to a defense lawyer

A careful and tenacious defense strategy can identify weaknesses in the prosecution's case. No matter how serious the charges against you, there are always things an experienced defense attorney can do to confront the prosecution and protect your civil rights.



No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Whether your arrest was minor or life-changing, never forget that you have
options. Your rights are important. Take advantage of your rights now.

Call 716-267-6430

Contact Us

Contact The Firm Help Is Available Now

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Firm Location

66 Park Circle
Amherst, NY 14226

Phone: 716-267-6430
Phone: 716-560-1171
Fax: 716-833-6208
Amherst Law Office Map